Dramatic Decreases in Automobile Donations in
2005 Hurt Legitimate 501 (c)(3) Non-profit
Organizations
Though never a large part of the budgets of most IRS sanctioned
non-profit organizations (NPOs), recent rulings by Revenue
Service (and instigated upon the recommendations of the General
Accounting Office and the Senate Finance Committee) have cut
automobile donations down quite a bit. Of course, there are
plenty organizations that promote the public good through
philanthropic and service missions that have need of
automobiles. In 2003, the GAO found over 4,000 of them as being
registered non-profits with the IRS and accepting automobile
donations.
That said, the volume of donations that originated from
automobile donations in most non-profits profiled were
minuscule compared with stock and property donations over $500.
Clothing and furniture donations to thrift stores represented a
large percentage of non-cash donations. availability,
automobile donations accounted for only 6% of an average NPO's
budget.
Of course, there is no such thing as the average NPO. What has
happened has been an increase in the number of people who are
selling their vehicles and putting the proceeds towards their
favorite charity or purchasing those stocks that will later be
donated when they've accrued more value. There are also plenty
of charities that actually do the selling themselves and take
the time to make sales part of their training mission. This
allows automobile donations to get a far higher price in the
sale, which is useful if your car should be worth more than
$500.
This also means that charities that can use a car directly have
great need of automobile donations, even though the
ever-present ads encouraging taxpayers to do so have become
somewhat less prominent since the 2005 tax law changes.
Generally, as ad revenues spent on advertising have gone down,
so have the frequency of useful automobile donations, and this
has sadly impacted some of the charities that can use those
types of donations the most: those that serve a disadvantaged
population directly through support or training.
As the practice of wholesale selling cars has gone by the
wayside, third-party agencies that facilitate automobile
donations have become somewhat less profitable, too. These
companies, sometimes founded as non-profit organizations
themselves, are now required to perform more accurate
bookkeeping. As such, the market has shifted a bit to states
that still allow these agencies to operate without oversight
and the estimated 5% of third-party agents who handle
automobile donations who have a non-profit mission
themselves.
Many prominent stories that drove congress to finally act were
also noted by the general public. Rates of giving declined
precipitously in the 2005 tax season, as deduction rates
decreased by as much as 90% when third-party agents handled
automobile donations.
This is significant, since nearly all the charitable automobile
donations in the United States were actually handled by
third-party agents – usually for-profit businesses that are
only very loosely regulated. At its peak in 2004, vehicle
donation programs were thought to represent nearly $1 billion
in reported automobile donations.
Partly the impetus for such legislation is the desire to curb
any activity that uses charitable donations for private gain.
But perhaps just as important to those in the halls of
government are the lost revenues represented by the disparity
between the revenues actually reported to NPOs versus the
amount deducted from individual returns, even legally according
to the law as it was written.
Regardless, charities that continue to benefit greatly from
automobile donations include many valuable organizations, such
as those who directly serve the poor with gifts of vehicles
that can mean the difference between a paying job or not.
Sometimes the only place one can find available in their price
range is out of the range of public transit. Charities that
handle automobile donations thusly are always looking for cars
and trucks that require minnimal work to be made drivable and
capable of being registered in the state.
Other programs include high school or college classes that
teach repair classes with automobile donations. Though the
market has fallen out of turning over automobile donations for
quick profit, charities that legitimately can use your gift
remain.
|